Zürich Limmatufer

Which One Is the Best Private Bank in Switzerland?

The answer to the question of which private bank in Switzerland is the best is not simply “Bank Meier” or “Dupont Private Banquiers,” as every client has different needs. For this reason, we will examine the relevant evaluation criteria and highlight the key factors you should consider when choosing the Swiss private bank that best suits your requirements.

Would you like our assistance in finding your individual best private bank in Switzerland or a fitting independent wealth manager? If so, please outline your needs and take advantage of a free consultation.

Geld anlegen in der Schweiz

Are Returns or Costs More Important When Choosing a Private Bank?

What is important about the offering of a private bank? Most investors cite the returns achieved as the most important factor: Is the best private bank the one with the highest returns? This brings us to the first question: How do you assess the performance?

  • Private banks do not disclose their returns on their websites. However, diversified mutual funds can provide some clarity. Those private banks that offer their investment strategies as mutual funds are required to publicly disclose returns. However, the majority of private banks do not offer such products, and consequently, the returns are not publicly accessible.
  • The assessment of returns achieved is always dependent on the risks taken. Risky strategies tend to yield higher returns in the long run compared to conservative investments, although the opposite can be true short-term. Only by understanding the risks can one properly evaluate the return. Additionally, risk metrics are only publicly available if investment strategies are offered as mutual funds.
  • The risk-return ratio is typically calculated using the Sharpe ratio. However, outsiders do not have access to the fundamentals needed to calculate the Sharpe ratio. This figure must also be requested from the bank.

For outsiders, evaluating the returns of a private bank is nearly impossible due to the lack of necessary information.

In recent years, costs have increasingly come into focus, which is a positive development. However, a one-sided focus on costs means that providers with low costs and returns can appear more favorable. The costs of wealth management represent the price for a service, which can vary greatly in quality. Relevant for assessing the performance of a private bank is the net return, i.e., the return after deducting all costs.

What Scope of Advice Does a Private Bank Offer?

The differences in the scope of advisory services provided by private banks are huge. Therefore, it is important for clients to clarify their needs before selecting a provider. Frequently requested advisory topics include:

  • Real estate advice
  • Tax consulting
  • Retirement planning
  • Inheritance planning
  • Coordination of personal and business assets

Simpler issues can usually be addressed by in-house bank advisors. For more complex questions, external specialists are brought in. The general rule of thumb is: the larger the bank, the broader the advisory services offered. Smaller providers often focus almost entirely on asset management and consulting. Is the best private bank the one with the largest range of services? For most clients, this is not the case, as their advisory needs are typically limited to one or two specialized topics.

Beratung im Private Banking
Fairness im Private Banking

What Does Fairness Mean for a Private Bank?

In banking, there is typically a significant information asymmetry: the advisor has access to much more information than the customer. In this situation, there is always the risk that customers are sold products that benefit the seller but not the buyer. Therefore, fairness and decency from the bank are essential. The best private bank must therefore manage the delicate balance between customer interests and bank interests.

Private banks that focus on maximizing profits compromise on fairness. They provide their advisors with incentives to place as many high-margin products in customer portfolios. Our experience shows that family-owned private banks pay more attention to fair business practices than publicly listed banks. Owner-managed banks have a longer time horizon since they do not need to present profit increases to their shareholders every quarter. Long-term thinking leads to a greater focus on customer interests rather than short-term profit maximization.

Are There Publicly Available Rankings of Private Banks?

Yes, they do exist, but the significance must be assessed with nuance.

  • BILANZ: In search of the best private bank in Switzerland, BILANZ magazine evaluates approximately 80 banks each year based on a specific customer case. The assessment is very detailed, focusing primarily on competence, costs, and the transparency of the specific offer. The limitation of significance is mainly due to two factors:
    • Can the quality of a private bank really be judged based on the approach taken in a single case?
    • The returns achieved by the banks are not considered.
  • firstfive/BILANZ: firstfive is a company that specializes in the verification and assessment of performances. The best asset managers are awarded annually in BILANZ based on firstfive data. The data from firstfive is robust and reliable. However, so far, only universal banks and independent wealth managers have participated in these comparisons. Private banks mostly prefer to remain discreet. FinGuide represents firstfive in the Swiss market, which is why we are involved in these comparisons.
  • Awards: In banking, various awards are given for exceptional achievements. In most cases, the business model involves offering awards for a fee. Often, engaging in paid consulting or placing advertisements can help in winning an award. Therefore, awards should be approached with great caution, as they are often not indicative.
Ranking von Schweizer Privatbanken
Wegweiser im Schweizer Private Banking

Conclusion

THE best private bank in Switzerland for all clients does not exist. Individual customer needs must be considered when making a selection. If you are considering becoming a client of a private bank, be sure to ask for the following information:

  • Proof of net returns over several years in the risk class relevant to you.
  • Is there an external audit of these return figures? Or are the strategies managed as investment funds?
  • What is included in the stated costs and what is not? Are additional wealth management or advisory fees charged for proprietary products? What margins apply to foreign currency transactions?
  • Are all advisory topics that are relevant to you covered?
  • How are the bonuses for customer advisors determined? Can potential conflicts of interest be derived from this?

If you want to simplify the process, find your best private bank with FinGuide. We leverage our expertise for you and have already gathered all the essential information about the best private banks.

Tested Private Banks

FinGuide has reviewed various private banks, and most have failed our quality tests. The main reason is that most private banks set their advisors sales targets on their own products. These products often hide additional margins within customer portfolios. So far, five have qualified for the FinGuide platform.

Baumann & Cie: Baumann & Cie is a well-established private bank from Basel with branches in Zurich and Olten. The three partners are personally liable with their own assets.

Globalance Bank: Globalance Bank in Zurich is a pioneer in sustainable investments. No other bank has committed so consistently to sustainability.

Helvetische Bank: Helvetische Bank in Zurich combines the flexibility and agility of an independent asset manager with a banking license and fair conditions.

Maerki Baumann: Maerki Baumann in Zurich is 95% family-owned and thus oriented towards long-term goals. Among private banks, it is a pioneer in crypto investments.

Reichmuth & Co. Privatbanquiers: Reichmuth in Lucerne, Zurich, and St. Gallen embodies entrepreneurial action, with partners personally liable for the bank.

FinGuide not only evaluates private banks but also independent wealth managers. A compilation of all private banking providers that have qualified for our platform can be found on our partner page.

Geld anlegen in Zürich

We are here for you!

Which wealth management provider is best for you?